Caleb Promised Big on Monday and It Was Gone by Thursday

By Melissa Whitaker

The word morning turns up in Hosea 6:3 and again in 6:4, and it does opposite jobs. In verse 3 the Lord's going forth "is prepared as the morning", which is as sure as a sunrise. In verse 4 the people's goodness "is as a morning cloud", and "as the early dew it goeth away." One thing you can count on and one thing that's gone by breakfast, with the same word holding up both.

This is the reading for the week of November 16 (Hosea 1-6, 10-14 and Joel). Hosea is about Israel and the Lord and has nothing to say to eleven-year-olds as such.

Who is talking in Hosea 6:1-4?

Look at who speaks in the first three verses. It's a group. "Come, and let us return unto the Lord," it starts, and then "we shall live in his sight" and "Then shall we know, if we follow on to know the Lord." The text doesn't say who is talking, but with all those "us" and "we" words it reads like a people making up their own minds to come back, a resolution and a sincere-sounding one.

Then verse 4 comes straight after it.

O Ephraim, what shall I do unto thee? O Judah, what shall I do unto thee? for your goodness is as a morning cloud, and as the early dew it goeth away.

Hosea 6:4

Verse 4 doesn't name its speaker either. It's usually read as the Lord because verse 5 says "have I hewed them by the prophets" and verse 6 says "I desired mercy, and not sacrifice." It also opens with a question, "what shall I do unto thee?", which sounds to me like somebody at a loss and not somebody sentencing anybody.

Verse 5 is harsh, no question. But verse 4 itself says only that the goodness goes away. It says nothing about the goodness having been put on, and the word for treachery waits until verse 7.

What I did on Saturday instead

On Monday, November 2, at dinner, Caleb put his fork down and announced that he was going to throw fifty balls at the rebounder net by the trampoline every day after school until spring. He meant it. You could see him meaning it. David said that was great and I said that was great and Lily asked if she could also do something every day, which Ben took as a cue to throw a pea.

He did it Monday. He did it Tuesday. On Wednesday it was cold and he came in and went straight to the pantry. I was at recipe testing until five, and by the time I got home nobody, me included, was thinking about the net.

On Thursday I asked at four o'clock if he'd done his throws, and at half past five I asked again, in a voice I was proud of for being so casual. He hadn't. I said, "You told us every day," once, the way I try to say any warning (that's what the watchman post is about), and he said, "I know," and gave me the look of a person whose private notebook has just been read aloud at the table.

On Saturday morning, while he ate cereal standing at the counter with his hair flat on one side, I said fifty was a lot for a cold week in November and asked what he'd really do every day. He thought about it and said five. Asking twice on Thursday hadn't helped, so I didn't push the number up.

Five throws, when he comes in the door, before he takes his backpack upstairs, and the ball sits on the third stair so he has to step over it.

I don't check. At dinner he says "done" or he doesn't, and if he doesn't I say nothing and he carries the ball to his room. It's been a little over a week and he's missed three that I know of.

Why five throws beat fifty

What helped was tying the promise to a place and a time, since a doorway can remind him every day and I can't do it kindly forever. Researchers who study this kind of if-then plan ("when I come in the door, I throw five") have mostly tested it on adults, and it does seem to help people follow through. The number I go back to is from a study of adults who each picked one small daily habit and rated how automatic it felt. On their own reports it took 66 days on average, with a range from 18 days to a projected 254. Those were adults, so I won't pretend it describes Caleb, but it tells me a week and a bit is early.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Hosea 6:4 say the people's goodness was fake?

No. It says the goodness goes away, like a morning cloud or the early dew. The charge of treachery is in verse 7, and I'd keep it there.

Is a child who drops a promise by Thursday lying?

Not in my house, not about this. On Monday the promise was true, and by Thursday something else was louder. That's an eager eleven-year-old, and I do the same with my own resolutions. I told myself in October that I'd write the week's dinners on the legal pad every Sunday night, and it has been Tuesday more often than Sunday.

What did Joel mean by rending the heart?

Joel 2:13 says "rend your heart, and not your garments." The Come, Follow Me manual explains that tearing your clothes was an outward sign of mourning or remorse, so the verse is asking for the inward thing and not just the sign of it. It goes on to say why: "for he is gracious and merciful." I'd keep that reason with the command.

How long should I give a new routine?

Longer than you think, and with fewer things in it. My own guess, and only a guess, is a month for five throws or five pages before you judge it. The study of adults I mentioned averaged 66 days. If it fades, make it smaller and try again.

What I'd do this week

Pick one thing, and make it small enough to do in under two minutes. Attach it to a place and a moment that already happens, like the doorway or the stairs. Decide what you'll say about it (for me that's nothing) and let him be the one to report. Then start smaller than feels worth doing.

with love, Melissa